Google rewrites Finnegans Wake

I found this by accident a few weeks ago on YouTube while listening to a recording of James Joyce reading Finnegans Wake. I wasn’t even aware that YouTube had the option to transcribe the audio into words and just came across it while I was messing around with some settings for the video.

It starts off fairly good actually and manages to get the first five words correct, but after that it just loses all track of what Joyce is saying and decides to start making up its own storyline instead.

YouTube does say that Google’s audio transcription service is in “beta” but it’s amusing none the less seeing it try to modernize the story with words like “portable player”, “President Clinton” and “1980 Olympic team”. (Bill Clinton makes an appearance 5 times oddly enough!)

Also on top of that the audio was recorded all the way back in 1929 so it doesn’t have much to work with in terms of audio quality.

 

 

Anyway here is Google’s version: (if your not familiar with the book watch the video below first and then read this)

Well you know or don’t think it never happened according to the beginning of containing and that he has this to you. Real quickly, court identical York a few on my work in Arizone, you’re the room. Okay here grade don’t know what Dan Quayle not of all proposals how it depends on where are those and when we return under old when by right but in not I want to belittle you could have been, meantime that the members that a contents of that and what are political bring with you, all the money that a world warmed by the way a month. clearly I don’t know. I agree with you, but in your mind and I didn’t bring mine or mine. It’s going to win, but I mean if you don’t want to try and pin a little didn’t he, I wasn’t going to break between and again ordinance went to the moon, I think I am I going to be able to hear it would be in corporate about it, in canton nine, portable player, ongoing political, a condom not and word contain the spill. We learned about the know it then we can, I don’t know, yeah. I don’t know about Kimberly thing, in kingdom gone, of corporate on, are going to be the unabomber. I really didn’t all agree with you. Can we move toward normal well again? we also understand that I consider that importantly and whatnot and what that means aid. I don’t I don’t condone been knocked down by a man the armed and we’re taken on board the union it and one of the people involved in turn that around golf but I’m not able or a popular standard. The state and government and government nobody brought back to normal. Well there that but also the mother if you’re going to use could get in between, you don’t need government who commit crimes. He attended a know I’m going to call. All right on parole or headquarters time don’t go to our. Were going with all he continued it isn’t going to get of the criminal referrals and on who wouldn’t than done but he warned gold mine, there were more have been week the whole row are help her. is that the grand canyon that he’s still at the moment I think back to writing novels they’re reporting to us on the lawn there, from there. in fact I went home thinking about the them but nobody was going to make a little bit the workplace are well. The problem from the right moment and I don’t want improper that’s what I know you were corporate help. I haven’t overruled overruled, I don’t particularly have a probably in Albany, they’re up there, I mean own though my god, President Clinton wanted g_a_t_t_ in Conway kind if conduct and thing well I think what Albany Hillary and it could go home and at some point evidence. it think it helps and pinned down don’t mark and intolerable, but I didn’t perform and important thing, welcome back to the question that in and only one million on hundred points or over so can we can go on line, Clinton called on would do anything for granted weekend at camp in Poland been undergoing a little coloured. Well Laurin opponent on top of people down, I think all of the a political asylum about government in big trouble. Coleman moment and opinion, in a different form. mm-hm the improvement. And here we are now only kind of creature, I think in a black party though, I don’t play a great the world undergone I really didn’t want to be a million integrity? I mean no single old handle them and today, the testimony and were going to do it on that including sentence I’m on. Our plan will Clinton may have begun article and the more than an inch armageddon come, back to me, in wait till I mean will we will. That he they believe that any the he did not warmly morrie, well meet again, we talk a little, possibly the it’s the only one on I cannot tell you how you would agree with me but uniquely I am going more money. And you’ve got to watch but it cannot the eternal those a contaminated, I think that’s within Cuba unevenly and those that take a week old bulls a little a long way morning bonnie all we are in school. what money.
.
I honestly can’t heroes tailhook scandal, I mean he had to cancel until he was acquitted on a limb bones who indirectly don’t mean old other England it is. Clinton or world against us. I think you can definitely in and indeed an interesting question and in the crown chanted at the meeting was and if you want a different kind called army of you and adopted at birth, or brown that or the floor. In Nineteen Eighty Olympic team played a little any the leading company in and I think he needs the need to be and of course to mourn of that meeting that who problems, and a little that it and then you couldn’t have been returned that the menu, although the political catalogs maybe the world and to be, no kidding me all states I wanted to articulate he’s going to take not mean that an eternity covered of the New York and the Nickelodeon, it was TV it didn’t leak. He had bought old again called when or in. Who wouldn’t know and the baloney. Meanwhile it, hello? Ron Goldman. He can’t and don’t know. And Hugh will prevail. Atkins didn’t want to go printing them the money bill at all, on the window, on hold, on board. Thank you, but Bill Clinton, Albany know ago, old all it more. The whole group and number and Katie Couric on the ocean. Oh yeah the legal system. All he does, wonderful, well I mean the and the on beyond those home. Candy and on in, and would and of movement on the envelope was on, and an Indian. My night, and the UK, those and most of them. it’s by the end of the world. It doesn’t fit the mold. No. I did.
.
I think for people who haven’t read Finnegans wake before this version nearly makes as much sense as the original (and almost as funny) and I personally find it a lot easier to read too! In the original Joyce tries to pack the whole story into the first page of the book but Google seems to do the opposite here and tries to pack most of the story into the last paragraph. It adds around 5 or 6 new characters to the plot in the space of a few sentences in an attempt to make something of a story before the video ends, but fails miserably…  much like it has with other attempts on YouTube.
.
Heres the video if you want to see for yourself. If you have a copy of the book, he is reading from page 213-216, or the Anna Livia Plurabelle episode which is the last few pages of part 1.
.
UPDATE (23/03/2011): Google has updated its Audio Transcription Feature, check out the new version here.
.

To turn on Google’s Transcribe Audio option just click on the arrow next to the CC button and select “Transcribe Audio”

 

 

(via: elektricforest)

Leave a comment

Subscribe Scroll to Top